What’s the Deal with Fresh Pet Food? Pros, Cons & What to Know

Blog | February 20th, 2025

dog and pet parent looking in fridge


Fresh pet food has become one of the biggest trends in the pet industry. With promises of better nutrition, improved digestion, and shinier coats, many pet owners are making the switch from traditional kibble and canned food. But is fresh pet food really worth the cost and effort, or is it just a fad? Let’s dive into what fresh pet food is, its potential benefits and downsides, and whether it’s the right choice for your furry friend.


Bonus: Click here for your chance to claim a PetSmart gift card.


What Is Fresh Pet Food?


Fresh pet food is made with real, whole ingredients like meats, vegetables, and grains, often without artificial preservatives, fillers, or by-products. Unlike traditional kibble, which is highly processed, fresh pet food is gently cooked and typically stored in the refrigerator or freezer to maintain freshness. 

Some brands deliver pre-portioned meals straight to your door, while others are available in refrigerated sections of pet stores. PetSmart and Petco each have fresh dog food sections in their stores and online. Popular brands like The Farmer’s Dog, Ollie, and Nom Nom have paved the way for this growing market, offering human-grade ingredients tailored to your pet’s needs. 


Dog with tongue out reaching paw for food


Potential Benefits of Fresh Pet Food


Many pet owners claim that switching to fresh food has led to noticeable health improvements in their pets. Some potential benefits include:

  • Better Nutrition – Fresh pet food typically contains fewer fillers, preservatives, and artificial ingredients, providing a more balanced and wholesome diet.
  • Improved Digestion – Since fresh food often contains higher moisture content and easily digestible ingredients, some pets experience fewer stomach issues and better stool consistency.
  • Shinier Coats & Healthier Skin – High-quality proteins and healthy fats can contribute to a shinier coat and reduced skin irritation.
  • More Energy & Vitality – Pets may be more active and playful when eating nutrient-dense meals.
  • May Help with Allergies – Limited-ingredient fresh diets can help pets with food sensitivities or allergies by avoiding common triggers.


Dog with bowl of raw food


The Downsides of Fresh Pet Food


While fresh pet food has many potential benefits, there are also some drawbacks to consider:
  • Cost – Fresh pet food can be significantly more expensive than traditional kibble, making it a big commitment for pet parents on a budget.
  • Storage & Convenience – Fresh food needs to be kept in the fridge or freezer, which takes up space and requires planning for storage and thawing.
  • Shorter Shelf Life – Unlike dry kibble, which can last for months, fresh food has a much shorter expiration date.
  • Transitioning Issues – Some pets may take time to adjust to fresh food, and sudden dietary changes can lead to digestive upset.


JustFoodForDogs food in a bowl


Is It Worth It? Factors to Consider


Deciding whether to switch to fresh pet food depends on several factors:
  • Your Pet’s Needs – Consider your pet’s age, health conditions, and dietary sensitivities. Some pets thrive on fresh food, while others do just fine on high-quality kibble.
  • Your Budget – If cost is a concern, a fully fresh diet may not be realistic, but there are affordable ways to incorporate fresh food.
  • Lifestyle & Convenience – Fresh food requires refrigeration, preparation, and a subscription or regular purchases. If you travel often or have a busy schedule, it might not be the most convenient choice.
  • Vet Recommendations – Always consult your veterinarian before making any major changes to your pet’s diet, as they can provide guidance based on your pet’s specific health needs.


Want to Try Fresh Pet Food for Free?


If you’re curious about fresh pet food but aren’t sure if it’s worth the investment, many brands offer free samples or trial discounts. This can be a great way to see if your pet enjoys fresh food before committing to a full subscription or purchase. Some companies provide small sample packs, while others offer heavily discounted first orders. Keep an eye out for promotions from top brands, as they often provide special deals for new customers.

Free samples available now: 

The Bear & The RatGet a rebate offer for frozen dog treat

Halo Holistic Dog FoodApply for a free sample

Primal Freeze-Dried Dog Food Apply for a free sample

Prime 100 SPD Fresh RollGet a coupon for a free sample 

Discounts available now:

The Farmer’s Dog50% off first box 

JustFoodForDogs50% off first autoship order; also available at Petco 

Ollie – 50% off first order; also available at Petco

Nom Nom – 50% off first order; they also have a sampler pack for $20; also available at PetSmart


Final Verdict: Is Fresh Pet Food Worth It?


Fresh pet food has its advantages, but it’s not the right choice for every pet owner. While many pets benefit from higher-quality ingredients and improved digestion, the cost and convenience factors can be challenging for some households. If you’re interested in trying fresh pet food, starting with a trial or sample can be a great way to test the waters. Ultimately, the best diet for your pet is one that meets their nutritional needs while fitting into your lifestyle and budget.


Related: Top 10 Cash-Back Apps You Should Download Today